For adventuring riders who need to carry a lot of water. Say you set off with a one liter bottle of water in your pack, and 2- one liter hoops, one on each side of the rim.
The stopper in the hoop would prevent the water from moving around. When the bottle was empty, an entire hoop would be drained to fill it.
This sounds like a bad idea, yet there is not all that many good places to carry water on a uni.
I think the unicyclist who made the original post hasnāt been seen around these parts in a while, so I would be very appreciative of feedback from anyone on this forum who has thoughts on this topic.
Do you think this idea of using three tubes (with or without inflating more than one of them) is a viable way of increasing the weight of the wheel (in the vicinity of the rim)? If so, would you do it the way the original poster described or would you do it differently in some way? If differently, how would you do it?
I realize that most people want a lighter wheel, not a heavier wheel, however, my aim in reviving this post is not to get into another debate about the pros and cons of a lighter wheel vs a heavier wheel, but rather to hopefully figure out a viable way of making a wheel heavier.
Fishing weights on the spokes or auto wheel weights for balancing tires on the rim have also been suggested, but it seems like the multiple tube method proposed by the original poster would be better. Anyway, I am very interested in hearing your thoughts on the tube method or any other good approach to making a rim heavier or wheel heavier (in the vicinity of the rim). Thanks!
If you want it really heavy, you could try filling the rim itself with lead shotā¦
Tape over the spoke holes as if you were making it ready to run tubeless and fill the rim up from the valve hole. To finish off put the valve stem in and finish up filling from a spoke hole. You could also spray in some expanding foam at the valve hole to seal it up and hold the shot in place. It might settle a bit after a while though. An easier and cheaper alternative would be sand (and it might make less of a rattling noiseā¦!)
It would seem like a good way to ruin a perfectly good rim and good luck if you have to change a spoke, but it would certainly make a 36" wheel pretty heavy.
I have only skim read the rest of the thread so apologies if something like this has been previously discussed.
When I first went to UNICON there was a guy who used to put a wrap of curtain weights in his rim. These are ideal as you buy them on a roll and they are small lead weights attached to a string. He used to have several wraps of them under the rim tape, then put the tyre back on.
In the same vein, you could cut strips of code-4 lead (lead flashing) and double-side tape them to the inside of the rim (even solder them together into a long lead ārim-tapeā if you want to be fancy) ā depending on the centre depth you might get a couple of layers and still manage to get the tyre on. That is probably a bit more practical than my suggestion of filling the actual rim with stuff.
@rogeratunicycledotcom and @DrD Thanks to both of you for your excellent suggestions. I would never have thought of either of those ideas and they are both very likely much better solutions than the multiple tube method.
Now that I intend to get back into skatepark riding again, I want to build a 36er that will have handling characteristics as close to my original steel rim Coker as possible, while also having as strong a wheel as possible. If anyone knows the weight of the steel rim wheel that came with the original Coker, that would be very helpful. I should have weighed it before I sold my steel rim Coker. Iām guessing that I will need to add somewhere between 2 - 3 pounds of weight to an aluminum rim to get it to around the same weight as the steel rim. I envision riding my heavier rim 36er (once built) for most of the skatepark obstacles I attempt, but like a golfer uses different clubs for different shots, I may choose to use my lighter 36er for some obstacles. I think it will be great to have both options available to me! This puts my geared 36er build on hold for a little while, but I am very eager to start riding at skateparks again, so while Iām somewhat bummed out to wait longer to get back on a guni, I will be psyched to be one step closer to getting back to the skateparks. And there are a ton of them in and around NYC and vicinity now!
@IvenBach The information quoted above from earlier in this thread are the main reasons why I wouldnāt consider filling the tube with water.
I had originally considered sticking those auto weights on the side of the rim, which might not be ideal due to the profile of the rim or the possibility of them coming loose. Somehow I didnāt think of sticking them on the inside of the rim until you just posted! That may be an excellent option.
@IvenBach Interesting! I think I generally ride with around 50 psi, but I may reduce that by 5 - 10 psi for certain types of riding, once I get a bit further along. I think I previously rode at the lower tire pressure before my long break.
Thanks, I really appreciate your good wishes and positive energy! I have high hopes for my comeback, but I may very well be delusional, lol. Weāll see what happens once my wheel hits the skatepark pavement! Iām going to work my way back systematically, starting with the small stuff and going bigger and bigger as I progress, if I do well. At nearly 55, Iām not the same guy I was at 35 when I made my video, but Iām feeling good and I am fairly optimistic. All I can do is prepare and train the best I can, give it a try, and wish for a good outcome! I am hoping to find an up-and-coming videographer to film me if and when I reach the point where my riding is the least bit impressive. If and when I am satisfied with what Iām able to do on my 36er, I will definitely post a follow up video. Thanks again for your encouragement. It means a lot to me.
Iāve always ridden muni on a 24" with a 3" Gazzoloddi or Wildlife Leopard which have thick sidewalls and are pretty heavy compared to modern tyres. Now I ride a posh 27.5" Flansberrium with a carbon rim and 2.6" tyre with paper thin (still the thickest I could find) sidewalls.
I used to be able to plough over rocks really fast and maintain my momentum easily but with mordern tyres the bumps kill my momentum and itās really difficult to maintain speed.
Anyone know any 3" wide 27.5" tyres with āthickā sidewalls similar to the old Gazzās or Duroās?
That seems like an excellent suggestion. I started doing some research to see if it would be a viable solution, but I need to look into it further (or get additional information from forum members) before Iāll know one way or another. Based on information I found on the thread linked below, the original steel Coker rim was close to 3lbs heavier than the subsequent aluminum rim. In addition, the original Coker button tire was claimed to be around 5lbs, though I believe it is closer to about 3.25lbs. So depending upon the weight of the tire I get, I may need to add anywhere between three to maybe three and a half pounds of weight to the wheel (in the vicinity of the rim).
I havenāt done too much research on the puncture-proof liners yet, but the two brands I found quickly on Amazon (linked below) are about 3.5oz and 3.7oz per liner, respectively.
Since I probably need to increase the weight of the aluminum rim I purchase by at least 3lbs, Iād need nearly 13 of the heavier 3.7oz liners to achieve that additional three pounds of weight. As such, I assume that youāre probably suggesting that I add lead weights or something similar and then place the liner on top of the lead weights (or strips of code-4 lead flashing) that were suggested by the other forum members, is that correct? I donāt see how it could work any other way unless there are much heavier puncture proof liners on the market. If that is the case, I would be most interested in any information on the heavier liners (if you know of any) in order to save me the time of searching to see if I can find them. Even if I wind up having to use weights or a weighted strip, adding a liner as well makes sense, so your suggestion is quite good and I appreciate your input very much.
Even though our dear Duros were heavy for their small size, the key to their behavior was the sidewall stiffness (the weight was just a byproduct of nylonās properties).
I managed to experience the same thing with a Surly Nate in 60tpi but I donāt know if they made a 27.5 version since. But going for the 60tpi (instead of the foldable, higher-end versions), may provide a closer experience to what the Duro spoiled us with
Water would be easy to add weight but the problem is that the water (weight) would not be attached to the wheel and be free to flow in the tube. Also since there would likely be some air in the tube the water would tend to stay in the bottom of the wheel (at least at slower speeds) and cause a lot of drag/friction when the wheel rotates.
I use liquid in my tractor tires but it is only for added weight and not increased rotational momentum. Also in the tractor tire Iām not concerned about the added friction that is causes.
Have you considered eBike tyres? Scwalbe Eddy Current is listed at 1300g for a 27.5x2.8. I donāt think any modern tyre will be as thick as a Duro but that would not be far off in terms of weight
Thanks for all the suggestions. I found lead tape and I think this will be the best solution. This is the lead tape I plan to use:
At 36ā in diameter, my unicycle rim is about 113ā in circumference and since the tape is 2 grams per inch, each layer of two strips of tape will give me 452 grams (4 grams over 1lb). I will need to add about 3lbs of weight to my new Nimbus Dominator2 rim in order for it to equal the weight of my old steel rim. However, my old Wheel TA tire is about a half pound heavier than my Coker button tire, so if my Wheel TA tire will fit on my Nimbus rim, then Iāll only have to add about 2.5lbs of weight to the rim. Considering that the Nimbus Dominator2 36ā rim weighs 1173 grams (2.59lbs), Iāll still be more or less doubling the weight of my rim! And since this is the unicycle I want to use for riding ramps and other obstacles at skateparks, my question (to anyone who has some real knowledge of this sort of thing and isnāt just guessing) is:
Will uniformly (thanks to the lead tape) adding 2 ½ layers (5 strips of the lead tape) and doubling the weight of the rim significantly reduce the structural integrity of the rim? Will adding the 2.5lbs of lead weight to the rim make it substantially more susceptible to tacoing or failing in some manner? I considered adding one layer (2 strips) of the lead tape to the inside of the tire in order to reduce the amount of weight added directly to the rim, but I figured that probably isnāt such a good idea.
I now have all the parts (and the needed amount of lead tape) to start building my High Inertia 36er. However, before getting started I am curious to hear if anyone has any thoughts regarding the questions I posed. Thanks!
Maybe a bit off-topic: are you sure youāll be able to put the tire on with so much tape in the rim? I have had issues with a too big rim tape and a carbon 36er rim. The tire couldnāt be fitted inside and we burst it while trying and make it fit.