I visited that place, it didn’t seem all that big…
gaiaonline is huge, they have an MR with like 60000 pages, 20 posts to a page!!
it’s too confusing for me, what with the 50 or so subdivided forums, the admins/mods who flame everyone, etc. there isn’t that much traffic, but I still find it cluttered. I never got drawn to it like this forum.