can you notice a 5mm difference in crank lengths on a bike?

Hi,

I bought a new toy after selling my 29er. It’s a used Schwinn tandem. The right crank is straight, but the pedal is threaded into the crank hole at a slight angle creating an oscilating effect when I ride it. Rather than go for a helicoil fix, I thought I would search online for a match. It’s a drive side with a spider.

Turns out, I found one on Ebay for a buy it now of 10 bucks!. However, it’s supposed to be a length of 165 vs. the 170mm that is already on the tandem.

My question, would I notice the 5mm difference in cranks from the right side to the left side when rotating. Any thoughts?

You’ll notice the difference. That’s like having your seat height 5mm too short for one leg. 5mm in seat height on a road bike is very noticeable.

AE Bike sells Sugino tandem cranks.

JC’s solution, although viable, is somewhat simplistic. There is surgery available these days that will allow you to EASILY shorten one leg by 5mm to match your unmatched cranks. I recommend that you go this route, Rod, because I know you are a rebel.

When I first got my coker. One crank was a 125mm, and the other was 5 or 10mm larger than it. I never noticed until one day I went and wrecked and bent one crank out, and when going to buy a new rank, the sizes werent matching up.

You still get them to be matching though.

You will notice it.

I have ridden tandem, bicycle, fixed wheel, unicycle, trike and recumbent, and experimented with all manner of crank lengths. Trust me, you will notice it.

And you won’t like it.

I recently changed from 170mm cranks to 175mm cranks on my bike.

Very noticeable to me, but only when I’m sitting down pedaling. My seat is very low, and I ride a frame with a 14.5" seat tube.

how did you not notice that when looking at it Jerrick? surely that’s not hard to miss…

Eh, its only a few mm difference. I didnt notice it ever, and rode it for quite a few months, possibly a year before I bent the cranks and finally had to look at the cranks.

im going to go check my cranks now :smiley: