The thing that annoys me about such rants is that they aren’t about improving conditions for e have-nots, they’re about being nasty to the haves. A lot of arguments like that give me the impression that the commentators would be happy if everyone suffered a backbreaking recession, just so long as it hit the wealthy the hardest.
Imagine this:
Someone in a third world village is of the lower class of the village. Like all others of his class, he lives in a leaky and unsafe mud hut. There are a few wealthy people in his village, they live in sturdy wooden cabins with outhouses; the wealthy are about 10 times more rich than the poor villager.
One day, the poor villager finds a magic lamp. The genie tells him that whatever he wishes for, his whole village will get, and if he does not like the wish, he can say a set of magic words, and the wish will be undone.
So, he makes a wish: he wishes to be more wealthy. Shazam!
Suddenly, his whole village is affected by the wish.
Now the villager goes home. Like all his neighbors, he now lives in a small modern frame house with working plumbing. Then they chance to look up on the hill where the wealthy live. In the place of the cabins, are vast mansions with solar panelling, satellite dishes, streets, swimming pools, and the works. In fact, these new mansions are so opulent that they reveal that the wealthy are now 100 times richer than the poor villagers.
Here’s the question: Is the villager who made the wish richer or poorer than they were before? Are they better off, or are they worse off than they were before they made the wish?
By the reasoning of many left theorists I have encountered and spoken with in the U.S., the villager, who now has drinkable water, an earthquake-resistant home, sanitary plumbing, and other things which will extend his expected lifespan, is now ten times worse off than they were before, and they should say the magic words. Why? Because their criteria has nothing to do with ABSOLUTE quality of life, they are only concerned with how much the guy down the street owns that they don’t.
I think that’s absurd, and wrong.